|

|
c
|
- Year-round Schools Are An Odius Idea.
Opinion - The Virginian-Pilot
They deprive kids of carefree childhoods, ignore the benefits of extended
vacations and operate on the false assumption that children suffer academic
amnesia when given a 10-week summer break.
We can only hope that in a decade or two, year-round schools will be tossed
atop the slagheap of American educational experiments.
There they'll join other failed gimmicks. Like the muddled ``modern math'' of the
1960s, the ``open classrooms'' of the '70s and today's foolish infatuation with the
whole-language approach to reading.
Nevertheless, the Virginia Beach school district recently announced that it is
expanding its year-round program to a fourth elementary school, even as Norfolk
and Suffolk are poised to scratch theirs.
The reason the Beach program is even mildly tolerable is that it institutes
year-round calendars only in schools with strong grassroots support. Best of all,
the district makes it easy for children to transfer out of these schools if their
parents object.
Five years ago, when 12-month calendars were gathering momentum in
Hampton Roads, I wrote an op-ed piece denouncing the idea. I argued that
summer breaks are not necessarily breaks in education. In fact, the leisurely
vacations of my childhood allowed me and my friends to shake off the numbing
shackles of schoolwork and embark on summerlong book benders.
Both of my parents worked. We had neither air-conditioning nor a pool. But my
summers were idyllic because I had a library card and a shade tree in the yard.
It was all I needed.
Our little library offered prizes for the most books read, and the competition
was fierce.
The summer I was 12 marked my immersion in French history. It began with a
book of historical fiction called ``Desiree,'' about the young silk merchant's
daughter who was ditched by Napoleon for the dazzling Josephine, and it ended
with a dizzying array of bloody books on the French Revolution.
The next summer I moved on to the labor movement, devouring dozens of tomes
about Eugene V. Debs, Samuel Gompers, Dorothy Day, Joe Hill and the
Molly Maguires.
That was also when the local librarian called my mother at work to tattle when I
tried to check out a yellowed copy of Karl Marx's ``Das Kapital.''
My wise mom, short on formal education but long on reading, told her to let
me have it.
Another summer, I discovered my Irish roots after finding a volume of poetry by
Yeats. It was impossible to read Yeats without wanting to know more about the
beguiling Maud Gonne. And once you met Maud Gonne, you had to learn about
the heroes of the Easter Rising of 1916.
It was a phase. But it was also an education.
The fact is, my summers of reading served me well. Better in many ways than the
interminable hours spent behind battered desks in New Jersey public schools.
To this day, I can't remember the dates of the Mesolithic period, or what the
Pythagorean theorem states, or how to conjugate German verbs.
But I can tell you about guillotines, Fenians and Dorothy Day's radical
thoughts on poverty.
Still, when I first lamented the arrival of year-round schools, some local educators
accused me of Luddite thinking. They said that those lazy summers I remembered
were as dated as the Hula-Hoops we played with back then.
Today's children need a competitive edge, they scolded. They don't have a moment
to waste.
Seems to me that's exactly what kids need today. Moments to waste.
They need a break from schedules and SOLS and organized sports.
They need time to play, daydream and read for pleasure.
Year-round schools are not the answer.
Our tax dollars would be better spent on a fleet of bookmobiles.
Reach Kerry at 446-2306 or at kerry.dougherty@att.net
BACK
|
|